Random concert review: The Replacements, Poplar Creek Music Theater, 10 August 1989
Posted in Music with tags bootlegs, chris mars, Music, nostalgia, paul westerberg, punk rock, slim dunlap, the replacements, tommy stinson on 26 April 2008 by vanillablue
I’ve had pretty good luck with live concerts for someone who doesn’t go to that many. Nearly every show I’ve attended has at least one indelible memory associated with it, and as a result I’ve spent tons of time scouring the internet for recordings of shows I’ve attended. Almost 20 years have passed since some of these gigs, so I thought I’d blog these memories before they’re erased from my rapidly fading memory. File this under pointless nostalgia if you want.
Mp3’s of the shows will be available for download when possible.
In my teens and twenties I was lucky enough to see a bunch of great shows–Naked Raygun at the Riviera, Superchunk and Guided by Voices at Lounge Ax, Elliott Smith at the Empty Bottle, Sugar at the Orpheum, and innumerable Bob Mould solo shows.
But nothing stands out more in my mind than the times I’ve seen Paul Westerberg perform. Like any self-respecting misfit Midwestern teen, I adored the Replacements. I got into them relatively late, only hearing about them in 1987 or so thanks to my cooler older brother, but since then not a day goes by without a ‘Mats song popping into my head. I could go on about how much the band meant to me, but just trust me–read Michael Azzerad’s chapter on the band in Our Band Could Be Your Life and you’ll get it.
I saw the Replacements twice. The first time was on the infamous Tom Petty tour, at Poplar Creek Music Theater in suburban Chicago. I was in hgh school at the time and didn’t have a car, so I managed to convince a friend to go and check out this band that was opening for Tom Petty. It was probably one of the first concerts I attended. Poplar Creek was a large amphitheater, and the two of us wound up way back on the lawn, seemingly miles away from the stage. I couldn’t see Chris Mars at all, and Slim Dunlap was hidden behind a post or something like that, but I remember being able to see Westerberg and Tommy Stinson fine.
I’ve heard alot about how awful they were at times on that tour, but this night was amazing. Years later, I landed a bootleg tape of the show, which (although it sounds like shit) confirmed my fading memories. The pavilion seats were almost completely empty when they went on stage. They opened with “Nightclub Jitters”, Paul wandering through the empty pavilion dressed in a way-too-large suit and goofy hat. Returning to the stage, they stormed through “Alex Chilton”. Paul changed the first verses’ lyric to “Standing right on campus / Would they stamp us R.E.M.“, which got a few raised eyebrows in the crowd. Raised eyebrows was just about the only reaction, actually–most people were sitting down, drinking and picnicking, totally ignoring the band. Tommy got pissed off about that pretty quickly, and started baiting the audience, leading to these priceless taunts:
- “If ya bought tickets to come see us, come on down and take these seats, they don’t give a shit.”
- “Popular Creek, right?”
- “You don’t know and you don’t care…Why don’t we just get drunk and shit up here all night?” To which Paul responded mock-reasonably, “You simply can’t do that anymore, Tom. You have to be respectful.”
- “We got ten minutes left, whadda ya wanna hear? Tom Petty? He can kick us off, we don’t give a shit.”
Tommy actually jumped into the seats at one point, seeming to scare some Petty fans sitting in the front row. Later he played sitting down for awhile. During the closing “Bastards” he threw a couple pitchers of beer at the people in the seats, then smashed his bass to the ground and used the fragments like a club to trash his amp. Following that, all of them gathered around a mic and whistled the theme from the Andy Griffith show. And after that kiss-off to uncomprehending Petty fans, they staggered off the stage. After all these years, it’s still the most incredible performance I’ve seen.
“Bastards of Young” live at the Orange County Speedway on 18 August 1989, about a week after I saw them. Crowd seems a lot more appreciative.
The Pixies also played in Chicago that night, at the Metro. I later heard that the ‘Mats headed over to Wrigleyville after their set, and were in the audience for the Pixies gig. Wish I’d thought of doing that.
I’ve been thinking about this show since the ‘Mats first four albums were just re-released on Rhino. Here’s mp3’s of the show from a bootleg I obtained from the good folks at Color Me Impressed a few years ago, after searching for it for more than a decade. Funny, the crowd doesn’t seem as overtly hostile as I remember, but maybe they were just cheering so the ‘Mats would get off stage.
The Replacements: Poplar Creek Music Theater, Hoffman Estates IL, 10 August 1989. Download available for 7 days. The sound quality sucks–don’t say I didn’t warn you. Do not circulate these compressed files, please.


